As lavish influencer existence, wealth flaunting, and hauls dominate social media feeds, we shouldn’t be stunned that extreme consumption has develop into the default way of life. We see closets crammed to the brim with low cost, throw-away objects and having the most recent gadget arsenal as signifiers of an aspirational life.
Consumerism, nonetheless, is greater than a cultural development; it’s the spine of our financial system. Firms eagerly drive extreme consumption as a rise in gross sales is straight related to a rise in revenue.
Whereas we realized to just accept this stage of fabric consumption as regular, we must be reminded of the large environmental affect that comes together with it. As Yvon Chouinard, founding father of Patagonia, writes in a New York Occasions article:
“Obsession with the most recent tech devices drives open pit mining for valuable minerals. Demand for rubber continues to decimate rainforests. Turning these and different uncooked supplies into closing merchandise releases one-fifth of all carbon emissions.”
— Yvon Chouinard
Within the paper, Scientists’ Warning on Affluence, a gaggle of researchers concluded that decreasing materials consumption at the moment is important to keep away from the worst of the looming local weather change within the coming years. This want for reducing consumption can be mirrored within the UN’s Sustainability targets, particularly Purpose 17, “Guaranteeing sustainable consumption and manufacturing patterns”.
For a very long time, design has been a device for shopper engineering by for instance, designing merchandise with artificially restricted helpful life (deliberate obsolescence) to make sure steady consumption. And if we need to perceive particularly UX design’s function in influencing how a lot and what individuals purchase, we’ve to take a deeper have a look at pushy on-line purchasing experiences.
Right now, most on-line purchasing experiences are designed with persuasion, gamification, nudging and even deception to get unsuspecting customers so as to add extra issues to their basket.
There are “Hurry, just one merchandise left in inventory” kind messages and countdown clocks that exploit well-known cognitive biases to nudge customers to make impulse buy selections. As Michael Keenan explains,
“The shortage bias says that people place a better worth on objects they imagine to be uncommon and a decrease worth on issues that appear ample. Shortage advertising and marketing harnesses this bias to make manufacturers extra fascinating and enhance product gross sales. On-line shops use restricted releases, flash gross sales, and countdown timers to induce FOMO — the concern of lacking out — amongst consumers.”
— Michael Keenan
To make shopping for issues fast and easy, we take away friction from the checkout course of, for instance, with the one-click-buy button. As practitioners of user-centered design, we would implement the button and say: because of this frictionless and simple checkout course of, we improved the shopper expertise. Or did we simply do an enormous disservice to our customers?
Gliding via the checkout course of in seconds leaves no time for the consumer to ask, “Do I truly need this?” or “Do I’ve the cash for this?”. Certainly, placing customers on autopilot to make inconsiderate selections is the purpose.
As a enterprise.com article says: “Click on to purchase helps clients full purchasing inside seconds and reduces the period of time they should rethink their buy.”
Amanda Mull writes from a consumer perspective about the way it has develop into “too straightforward to purchase stuff you don’t need”:
“The order took perhaps 15 seconds. I chosen my dimension and put the sneakers in my cart, and my cellphone mechanically crammed in my login credentials and added my new bank card quantity. You may at all times return them, I assumed to myself as I tapped the “Purchase” button. […] I had accomplished some model of the web checkout course of 1,000,000 occasions earlier than, however I by no means might bear in mind it being fairly so spontaneous and inconsiderate. If it’s going to be that straightforward on a regular basis, I assumed to myself, I’m cooked.”
— Amanda Mull
This quote additionally highlights that this inconsiderate consumption isn’t solely dangerous to the surroundings but additionally to the exact same consumer we are saying we heart our design course of round. The rising reputation of buy-now-pay-later providers, bank card debt, and private finance gurus to assist “Overcoming Overspending” are indicators that persons are spending greater than they’ll afford, an enormous supply of stress for a lot of.
The one-click-buy button isn’t about bettering consumer expertise however constructing an surroundings the place customers are “extra possible to purchase extra and purchase typically.” If we care to place this bluntly, frictionless and persuasive e-commerce design isn’t user-centered however business-centered design.
Whereas it’s not uncommon for design to be a device to obtain enterprise targets, we, designers, ought to be clear about who we’re serving and at what price with the facility of design. To reckon with our affect, first, we’ve to grasp the supply of energy we yield — the facility asymmetry between the designer and the consumer.
Energy Asymmetry Between Person And Designer
Think about a scale: on one finish sits the designer and the consumer on the opposite. Now, let’s take a listing of the sources of energy every occasion has of their fingers in an internet purchasing state of affairs and see how the size balances.
Designers
Designers are outfitted with information about psychology, biases, nudging, and persuasion strategies. If we don’t have the time to be taught all that, we are able to attain for an out-of-the-box answer that makes use of these precise psychological and behavioral insights. For instance, Nudgify, a Woocommerce integration, guarantees to assist “you get extra gross sales and scale back purchasing cart abandonment by creating Urgency and eradicating Friction.”
Erika Corridor places it this fashion: “When you’re designing, you make decisions on behalf of different individuals.” We also have a phrase for this: selection structure. Alternative structure refers back to the deliberate crafting of decision-making environments. By subtly shaping how choices are introduced, selection structure influences particular person decision-making, typically with out their specific consciousness.
On prime of this, we additionally acquire funnel metrics, behavioral information, and A/B take a look at issues to verify our designs work as meant. In different phrases, we management the surroundings the place the consumer goes to make selections, and we’re educated about methods to tweak it in a solution to encourage the selections we need the consumer to make. Or, as Vitaly Friedman says in one among his articles:
“We’ve realized methods to craft actually lovely interfaces and well-orchestrated interactions. And we’ve additionally realized methods to encourage motion to satisfy the venture’s necessities and drive enterprise metrics. In actual fact, we are able to make just about something work, actually.”
— Vitaly Friedman
Person
On the opposite finish of the size, we’ve the consumer who’s normally unaware of our persuasion efforts, oblivious about their very own biases, not to mention understanding when and the way these are triggered.
Fortunately, regulation round Misleading Design on e-commerce is growing. For instance, corporations are not allowed to make use of faux countdown timers. Nonetheless, these rules are usually not common, and enforcement is lax, so typically customers are nonetheless not protected by legislation towards pushy purchasing experiences.
After this overview, let’s see how the size balances:
After we perceive this energy asymmetry between designer and consumer, we have to ask ourselves:
- What do I take advantage of my energy for?
- What sort of “actual life” consumer conduct am I designing for?
- What’s the affect of the customers’ conduct ensuing from my design?
If we have a look at e-commerce design at the moment, most of the time, the unlucky reply is senseless and extreme consumption.
This wants to vary. We have to use the facility of design to encourage sustainable consumer conduct and thus transfer us towards a sustainable future.
What Is Sustainable E-commerce?
The dialogue about sustainable e-commerce normally revolves round recyclable packaging, inexperienced supply, and making the location energy-efficient with sustainable UX. All these actions and angles are vital and ought to be a part of our design course of, however can we construct a very sustainable e-commerce if we’re nonetheless encouraging unsustainable consumer conduct by design?
To realize actually sustainable e-commerce, designers should shift from encouraging impulse purchases to supporting considerate selections. As an alternative of utilizing persuasion, gamification, and deception to spice up gross sales, we should always use our design expertise to offer customers with the time, house, and data they should make conscious buy selections. I name this strategy Type Commerce.
However The Enterprise?!
Whereas the intent of designing Type Commerce is noble, we’ve a bitter actuality to take care of: we stay and work in an financial system based mostly on perpetual development. We are sometimes measured on attaining KPIs like “elevated conversion” or “lowered cart abandonment price”. We’re anticipated to make use of UX to attain aggressive gross sales targets, and infrequently, we’re not ready to vary that.
It’s a irritating state of affairs to be in as a result of we are able to argue that the system wants to vary, so it’s potential for UXers to maneuver away from persuasive e-commerce design. Nonetheless, system change received’t occur except we push for it. A catch-22 state of affairs. So, what are the issues we might do at the moment?
- Pitch Type Commerce as a solution to construct robust buyer relationships that can have larger lifetime worth than the short buck we’d make with persuasive tips.
- Spotlight lowered prices. As Vitaly writes, utilizing misleading design may be expensive for the corporate:
“Add to basket” is fantastically highlighted in inexperienced, indicating a manner ahead, with insurance coverage added in mechanically. That’s a transparent darkish sample, after all. The design, nonetheless, is more likely to drive enterprise KPIs, i.e., enhance a spend per buyer. However it would additionally generate a fallacious buy. The implications of it for companies could be extreme and irreversible — with loads of complaints, buyer help inquiries, and excessive prices of processing returns.”
— Vitaly Friedman
Serving to customers discover the fitting merchandise and make selections they received’t remorse may help the corporate save all of the sources they would wish to spend on coping with complaints and returns. On prime of this, the corporate can save thousands and thousands of {dollars} by avoiding lawsuits for unfair industrial practices.
- Spotlight the growing buyer demand for sustainable corporations.
- For those who really feel that your organization isn’t open to vary practices and you might be annoyed concerning the dissonance between your day job and values, contemplate searching for a place the place you possibly can help an organization or a trigger that aligns together with your values.
A Few Rules To Design Conscious E-commerce
Add Friction
I do know, I do know, it seems like an insane proposition in a career obsessive about eliminating friction, however hear me out. As an alternative of “serving to” customers glide via the checkout course of with one-click purchase buttons, including a step to evaluation their order and provides them a pause might assist scale back pointless purchases. A optimistic reframing for this method might be useful to precise our true intentions.
As an alternative of claiming “including friction,” lets say “including a protecting step”. One other instance of “including a protecting step” might be eliminating the “Fast Add” buttons and making customers go to the product web page to try what they’re going to purchase. For instance, Natural Fundamentals doesn’t have a “Fast Add” button; customers can solely add issues to their cart from the product web page.
Inform
As soon as we be sure that customers will go to product pages, we may help them make extra knowledgeable selections. We may be clear concerning the social and environmental affect of an merchandise or present pointers on methods to look after the product to final a very long time.
For instance, Asket has a piece referred to as “Lifecycle” the place they spotlight methods to look after, restore and recycle their merchandise. There may be additionally a “Full Transparency” part to tell about the fee and affect of the garment.
Design Calm Pages
Aggressive touchdown pages the place the whole lot is transferring, blinking, modals popping up, 10 totally different reductions are introduced are overwhelming, complicated and distracting, a fertile surroundings for impulse selections.
Respect your consumer’s consideration by designing pages that don’t elevate their blood strain to 180 the second they open them. No modals mechanically popping up, no flashing carousels, and no low cost dumping. Goal for static banners and show presents in a transparent and clear manner. For instance, H&M exhibits just one banner highlighting a reduction on their touchdown web page, and that’s it. If a quick style model like H&M can design calm pages, there isn’t a excuse why others couldn’t.
Be Trustworthy In Your Messaging
Faux urgency and social proof can’t solely get you fined for thousands and thousands of {dollars} but additionally can flip customers away. So merely don’t add urgency messages and countdown clocks the place there isn’t a actual deadline behind a suggestion. Don’t use faux social proof messages. Don’t say one thing has a restricted provide when it doesn’t.
I’d even take this a step additional and advocate utilizing persuasion sparingly, even when they’re sincere. As an alternative of overloading the product web page with each potential persuasion technique (urgency, social proof, incentive, assuming they’re all sincere), select one but impactful persuasion level.
Disclaimer
To make it clear, I’m not advocating for designing unhealthy or cumbersome consumer experiences to hinder clients from shopping for issues. After all, I desire a pleasant and simple manner to purchase issues we want.
I’m additionally nicely conscious that design is rarely impartial. We have to current choices and organize consumer flows, and whichever manner we select to do this will affect consumer selections and actions.
What I’m advocating for is no less than placing the consumer again within the heart of our design course of. We learn earlier that customers suppose it’s “too straightforward to purchase stuff you don’t want” and really feel that the present state of e-commerce design is contributing to their extreme spending. Understanding this and calling ourselves user-centered, we ought to vary our strategy considerably.
On prime of this, I’m advocating for increasing our perspective to think about the broader environmental and social affect of our designs and align our work with the transfer towards a sustainable future.
Conscious Consumption Past E-commerce Design
E-commerce design is a sensible instance of how design is part of encouraging extreme, pointless consumption at the moment. On this article, we checked out what we are able to do on this sensible stage to assist our customers store extra mindfully. Nonetheless, remodeling on-line purchasing experiences is just part of an even bigger mission: transferring away from a tradition the place extreme consumption is the aspiration for purchasers and the final word purpose of corporations.
As Cliff Kuang says in his article,
“The designers of the approaching period want to think about themselves as inventing a brand new way of life that doesn’t privilege consumption as the one expression of cultural worth. On the very least, we have to begin framing consumption otherwise.”
— Cliff Kuang
Or, as Manuel Lima places in his guide, The New Designer,
“We want the design to refocus its consideration the place it’s wanted — not in creating issues that hurt the surroundings for a whole bunch of years or in promoting issues we don’t want in a steady push down the gross sales funnel however, as a substitute, in serving to individuals and the planet clear up actual issues. […] Designs’s final venture is to reimagine how we produce, ship, devour merchandise, bodily or digital, to rethink the present enterprise fashions.”
— Manuel Lima
So buckle up, designers, we’ve work to do!
To Sum It Up
Right now, design is a part of the issue of encouraging and facilitating extreme consumption via persuasive e-commerce design and thru designing for corporations with linear and exploitative enterprise fashions. For a habitable future, we have to change this. On a tactical stage, we have to begin advocating and designing conscious purchasing experiences, and on a strategic stage, we have to use our information and expertise to elevate sustainable companies.
I’m not saying that it’s going to be a simple or fast transition, however the very best time to begin is now. In a dire state of want for sustainable transformation, designers with energy and company can’t keep silent or proceed proliferating the issue.
“As designers, we have to see ourselves as gatekeepers of what we’re bringing into the world and what we select to not deliver into the world. Design is a craft with duty. The duty to assist create a greater world for all.”
— Mike Monteiro
(yk)